This video playfully highlights the dangers of making lazy caricatures of political opponents by flattening complexities and multiple variables into a simplistic framework in an ironic twist. It demonstrates the irony so well I am not sure how much was fully intentional, which makes things more interesting. In the first section under “shared ideologies” it frames the liberal as wanting to use the government to force their ideas on the population and Hitler agrees. But I don’t think there is any context in which a law governing behavior would not be considered force of some kind.
And contrary to what the video implies, despite his use of the word socialist to promote his party, Hitler didn’t like socialists in the common sense of the term. “Dachau, the first Nazi concentration camp, was built in March 1933 to imprison political opponents. The Communist Party (KPD) was banned in March 1933, trade unions were disbanded in May and the Social Democrats (SPD) abolished in June. Leaders of these parties and unions were arrested or fled into exile. By the end of 1933, there were almost 27,000 people imprisoned in concentration camps, and the majority of these were political prisoners.”( Holocaust Memorial Day Trust | Political opponents and trade unionists).
So while it may be tempting it is not good enough to try to judge who is good or bad simply based on a label they share with someone else. And one of the things this video did well was to highlight how caricatures make people and their concerns far easier to dismiss in theory than in reality. I think it is very important that in our zeal for whatever good we want in the world that we don’t hurry to dismiss and dehumanize others no matter how right we think we are and to stay humble enough to address our own hypocrisy and blind spots. There is no perfect godly party on earth so rather than focusing so much time on how much you think another person is similar to Hitler or not ask yourself where you fall short of righteousness and ask what behaviors remind you of Yeshua the most and aim to make your main goal reflecting God’s love rather than falling into the group think of “right” vs “left”.
“Now I, Paul, appeal myself to you by the meekness and gentleness of Messiah…For the weapons of our warfare are not fleshly but powerful through God for the tearing down of strongholds…If anyone is confident in himself that he belongs to Messiah, let him reconsider that just as he belongs to Messiah, so also do we…For we do not dare to classify or compare ourselves with some of those who commend themselves. But when they measure themselves by themselves and compare themselves with themselves, they have no understanding.” 2 Corinthians 10:1-12
